Mezzanine Mark

Tuesday, August 03, 2004

What? Does Anyone get this?

Portion of a transcript of Kerry/Edwards interview Sunday on Fox News. If you click the post you can read the whole transcript. I encourage all my readers, regardless of political affiliation, to read the whole transcript too; It's not often these days in a high-profile campaign that you get to hear the words right out of a candidate's mouth rather than having it be filtered by slews of political advisors who produce formulaic speeches.

Kerry and Edwards (not surprisingly) come across as intelligent. This one bit I've stuck below though I think at least partially validates some of the stereotype Kerry has received as a flip-flopping panderer to whatever it is people want to hear. Not saying the whole interview was that way, not even saying the characterization is justified in all cases...it's just that below he is engaging in some pretty shady wordspeak. see below....



WALLACE: Senator Kerry, in your convention speech, just on this point, you said let's be optimists, not opponents, let's take the high road. But in your speech, you said the president misled us into war. You said that he's playing...

KERRY: No, I said we'll never mislead us into war.

WALLACE: Well, the implication was this president did.

KERRY: Well, I said...

WALLACE: And, in fact, you said he did.

KERRY: I said he did — correct, and I have said it several times.

WALLACE: And...

KERRY: In the speech I didn't, and you're quoting my speech.

WALLACE: Right.

KERRY: I didn't say that. I said I will never mislead us.

WALLACE: But you don't disagree with the premise that you have said that he misled us?

KERRY: Well, all Americans understand what's happened now.



He said he didn't, then he said he did, and then he blows it all off when he claims that all Americans know what happened. Well did he or didn't he? And I don't think all Americans know what happened....but I do think most if not all Americans would LIKE TO KNOW what happened. Big distinction there Mr. Senator.

12 Comments:

  • I saw that interview. This is a good example of how reading something, with the absence of context, inflection, tone and pacing, can be misleading. Things look different in writing. I'm sure we've all had the experience of something sounding harsher in an email than we meant it to. Or, of our intended irony not being conveyed. It can be frustrating.

    When I saw this live, I didn't see it as "shady wordspeak". Although I will admit that when I read it here, it appears so. I saw it as him trying to get across the point that yes, he has said that the president misled us, but he didn't say it IN THE SPEECH. Wallace specifically asked about the speech and Kerry was trying to anchor his answer IN THE SPEECH. Wallace created the confusion by interrupting, and then saying things like "but that's what you meant" or "but you don't disagree with the premise". It seemed more to me that Wallace was flustered at being corrected and was trying to salvage his question.

    At least that was the way it came across to me...and I hope the fact that I was watching Fox News is evidence of my attempt to be less partisan and more open to Other's Opinions.....ahem. If nothing else, I'm getting quite the education on how Others Think. ;^)

    --L.B.

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 3:43 AM  

  • The man is a beacon of clarity.

    --M

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 4:32 PM  

  • Another note. If I ever run for politics (yeah), I'm going to propel my way to office by saying things, and that flatly denying ever having said them, even to reporters staring down at the transcripts.

    --M

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 4:33 PM  

  • you bastard...you had to use BEACON didn't you????? hehe

    By Blogger Mark, at 4:36 PM  

  • Hey, I think "flip-flopper" is a pretty lame charge, but for those who put a lot of importance on avoiding the temptation to change one's mind, I give you http://www.americanprogress.org/site/pp.asp?c=biJRJ8OVF&b=42263

    By Blogger Alex, at 12:11 AM  

  • Hey Alex,

    I checked out the link. The link makes some good points on some of the stuff, with the most conspicuous example in my mind of the Bush flip flop being the Condoleeza Rice testimony debacle. First she couldn't despite her deisre to, due to historical precendent, and then all of a sudden she could. That was pretty weak. And in the ruthless exercise of political character assasination that eventually takes place in every campaign,people spend oodles of mone trying to paint undesirable portraits of their opponents when arguably they are guilty of the same thing. The flip flopping portrait may be an example of the Bush camp doing it to Kerry, and I think the war in Iraq is an example of the opposite....as Kerry, based upon his vote, would have made the same decsion based upon the limited intelligence available at the time of the decision.

    Some of the stuff on the examples on site is a bit weak though, most notably some of the evidence of flip flops regarding political bills. The reason I say that is because there is often three to four years or more between quotes where Bush supports or goes against a bill. However as any political science person can tell you, over a multi-year span, bills can go through MANY permutations and undergo significant alterations to text due to to either legislative negotiation (in good cases) or pork barreling (in bad cases) which change the whole dynamic of the bill. Yet the bills keep the same name so that the intial sponsors of the bill get to pad their political resumes and egos. It's prett conceivable that many of the "flip-flops" regarding a bill that has a long debate time can be attrbiuted to supporting one permutation, but not another.

    Of course the same can be said of any legislative "flip-flops" Kerry is charged with pertaining to bills that have long discussion time in the Senate. That's part of the reason why, as you'll note, that I said in my post that the characterization of "flip-flop" isn't always justified.

    I posted these quotes, because they are just that, quotes, unfiltered by political advisers or partisan commentators. I think that kind of primary source is invaluable much more so than any politcal editorials by political beat writers. And so I thought it interesting that the transcripts lend evidence to flip flop, because i think they have more credence than partisan editorials.

    It's just one interview....and obviously the presidential debates will be where most if not all of the questions wil be answered for swing voters.

    By Blogger Mark, at 11:51 AM  

  • "for those who put a lot of importance on avoiding the temptation to change one's mind..."

    Alex, I love that phrase and I'm stealing it.

    -Lori

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 2:16 PM  

  • Yeah, I'm totally with you, Mark. One note I'd add is that while transcripts are definitely preferable to selective quoting, it's still possible to "bias" by choosing which section of a transcript to excerpt. Plus, as Lori pointed out, there's the visual and verbal cues which go missing in straight transcription. Not saying Republicans are any more likely than Democrats to utilize these tricks...but I can assure you that many direct transcriptions of W make him sound like a chimpanzee that can't string a coherent sentence together (same for his Dad, come to think of it).

    By Blogger Alex, at 9:38 PM  

  • I think the flip-flop fuss is annoying me (on behalf of both candidates) because the examples that are used are so completely decontextualized. There is a line (that the opponents of both candidates seem to enjoy blurring) between not taking a stand and taking a stand, then learning more and revising your original stand. People who DON'T do that scare me more than people who do. People who hold steadfastly to an original opinion, even in the face of conflicting (or better) information, do not earn my respect. It takes much more character to say "Yes, I used to think X. Then I learned Y and Z, so I adjusted my views on X."

    For certain, my own views on some pretty important issues have been all over the map. And you know what that proves? That I was THINKING about them. I wasn't just regurgitating what someone else wanted me to think. Saying "I reserve the right to change my mind" doesn't mean I am trying to have it both ways. It means that I am open to new information that may cause me to rethink my stance. It's dangerous for people to stop doing that. Especially those in leadership.

    So, I wish all this "flip-flop" flap would go away. The parties are trying to use it to imply that one candidate or the other can't/won't take a stand on issues or are trying to be all things to all people. And I think in the cases of Bush and Kerry it's a pointless discussion with a distracting downward spiral. I will say, though, that it has provided an interesting window into the candidates' evolution of thought on certain issues (e.g. Vietnam).

    But that's just my opinion. I could be wrong...and I reserve the right to change my mind...

    --Lori

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 1:25 AM  

  • Oh...one more thing....I think Alex makes an excellent point about "selective quoting" even from transcripts. And even though I understand your motivation for doing it (you were specifically making a point about the flip-flop stereotype affixed to Kerry), your blog post is sort of an example of it, Mark.

    Arguably, someone who had only read your excerpt might get a much different idea about Kerry than someone who had watched the interview or read the complete transcript. Again, not meaning to imply that this was intentional on your part, but both parties make extensive use of this tactic quite deliberately and I think it insults and misleads the audience. Unfortunately most people don't have time to research the veracity of or motivations behind what they are being told, so it's a pretty effective (albeit shady) technique.

    Again, I know that this case is different--different motivation, different medium, different venue. But interesting, nonetheless.

    Have you noticed that I have become a crazed insomniac? I wish I could somehow change the timestamp on my comments so that it isn't obvious that I am up blogging at 1:45 a.m. I think it's time to cut out the caffeine...or stop going to the gym so late at night...

    --L.

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 1:56 AM  

  • You can say it's an example of selective transcripting Lori, but I disagree. As you pointed out, I chose the bit relevnt to the post, and even more importantly, I prefaced the whole thing, before even addressing the point of the post, buy linking to the coplete transcript ansd encouraging everyone to read it.

    Alex, your point about the talking chimpanzee is well noted. But think of it this way...chimpanzees are some of the smartest animals on earth...yet they can't talk....so the fact Bush can talk makes him ELITE!!! hehe. Keep the discussion coming.

    By Blogger Mark, at 9:56 AM  

  • I would never question that your motives are pure, Marky-Mark...of course that could be pure evil....muhahahaha!

    Muhahahahahaha!

    (I'm practicing my evil laugh....it's much better and scarier in person....sorry, it's the lack of sleep....)

    L.

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 12:57 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home